tehran_taj/docs/parity/ISSUES.md

ISSUES — logged, NOT fixed during parity

Anything found during the parity audit that is a bug, risk, smell or improvement opportunity goes here. Do not fix these while parity work is in progress (see CLAUDE.md §3). They are worked through in Phase 3, only when the user asks.

Severity: Critical (money loss / security / data loss) · High · Medium · Low

Paths are relative to the workspace root (gold bank/). "REF" = reference project (read-only). "TGT" = gold-banking-monorepo. Items marked [replicated] exist in the reference and were faithfully ported — fixing them is a product decision, not a parity fix.

Security & auth

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Suggested fix
SEC-01	Critical	REF henza_server/routes/admin.php:12,272	The whole admin route file is unauthenticated — the Route::middleware('auth:api')->group(...) wrapper is commented out at both ends, leaving all ~215 admin routes public (incl. wallet/charge, users, roles).	Verified by reading both lines.	n/a in reference (read-only). Drives TGT decision below.
SEC-02	Critical FIXED — hotfix stage 3	TGT apps/api/src/modules/accounting/accounting.controller.ts:7, orders/orders.controller.ts:7, customers/customers.controller.ts:5, catalog/catalog.controller.ts:5, pricing/pricing.controller.ts:5	15 routes carry @Public(), including ledger writes (POST accounting/repayments/*, entries/:id/confirm) and POST /api/orders + PATCH /api/orders/:id/status. The public status DTO accepts a client-supplied actorAdminUserId, so a caller can attribute an action to any admin.	grep -rn "@Public()"; source comments say "pre-existing unauthenticated endpoint".	✅ All closed across stages 1-3. Ledger + order-status behind admin rids; customer routes behind the customer JWT; POST /orders takes the customer from the token and ignores the body. Only catalog/products, pricing/latest, home/slider and uploads/:filename remain public, all by design.
SEC-03	Critical FIXED — hotfix stage 2	TGT apps/user-app/src/views/user/LoginView.vue, apps/user-app-v2/ same	OTP is not verified — any 4-digit code logs the user in. This is a parity gap: the reference does verify it (ApiMobileController.php:51-57, mismatch → HTTP 422).	DECISIONS.md D6	✅ Real server-side OTP: bcrypt-hashed code, 2-min expiry, 5 attempts, single use, send throttle, no enumeration. Verified end-to-end by auth-smoke.sh.
SEC-08	Critical FIXED — hotfix stage 2	TGT apps/api/src/modules/customers/customers.service.ts:6-23,44-50 + customers.controller.ts:10 (@Public())	Full customer book exposed to anonymous callers. Login downloads GET /customers and matches the phone client-side, so the endpoint returns every active customer with fullName, mobile, nationalCode, goldDebtGrams, fiatDebtRial, goldCreditLimitGrams, and the URLs of national-ID / business-licence / shop scans (and GET uploads/:filename is public too, so those URLs resolve). passwordHash is correctly excluded. Not possible in the reference, where userVerfiy returned one customer after the code matched.	Read customers.service.ts:5-23; DECISIONS.md D8	✅ Closed. The whole controller is deleted — no route accepts a customer id any more. Reads moved to token-derived /customer/me*. Stage 1 had only narrowed the fields, which left the ids and the :id routes exposed.
SEC-09	Critical FIXED — hotfix stage 1	TGT apps/api/src/modules/accounting/accounting.controller.ts:7	@Public() on the whole accounting controller exposes 5 routes, 4 of them writes: reconcile a balance, record a gold repayment, record a rial repayment, confirm a ledger entry. Faithful to the reference (whose admin routes were all unauthenticated) but contradicts the confirmed decision D1.	DECISIONS.md §"@Public audit" group A	✅ Done: rids wallet.list, wallet.charge, document.create ×2, document.list.confirm. Verified 401/403/pass-through by apps/api/scripts/auth-smoke.sh.
SEC-10	High FIXED — hotfix stage 1	TGT apps/api/src/modules/orders/orders.controller.ts:22	PATCH orders/:id/status is public and its DTO accepts a client-supplied actorAdminUserId, so an anonymous caller can move an order's status and attribute it to any admin. In the reference this was an admin operation.	DECISIONS.md §"@Public audit" B3	✅ Done: order.list.sts.submit. Had no caller — the admin panel uses admin/orders/status.
SEC-04	High	TGT apps/api (two files)	JWT_SECRET falls back to 'dev-only-insecure-secret' and is absent from .env.example. enableCors() is wide open.	Reported by api inventory; see _inv-tgt-api.md §11.	Require the env var at boot; restrict CORS origins.
SEC-05	High	TGT apps/api/prisma/seed.ts	Seed creates a SUPER_ADMIN (09128081392) whose password equals the phone number, holding all 144 rids. Marked DEV-ONLY in comments but lives in the normal seed.	docs/CHANGELOG-PORT-HISTORY.md §4 documents this as intentional for dev.	Gate behind an explicit env flag so it can never run outside dev.
SEC-06	High	REF henza_server	Hardcoded secrets committed to the repo: SMS panel password, PayPing bearer token, Tahesab bearer + IP allowlist, wallet hash pepper ("yhoenszeaf").	See _inv-ref-server.md §11.4.	Rotate all of them before any deployment that reuses these credentials.
SEC-07	Medium	TGT apps/api/src/modules/admin-customers/admin-customers.service.ts	setRoles stores arbitrary strings as rids with no validation against ALL_RIDS.	api inventory §9.	Validate against the rid catalogue.

Customer / person module (found during the user-requested deep check)

These are parity defects being fixed, not deferred items — see DECISIONS.md D0, D9, D10, D11. Listed here so the trail is complete.

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Status
CUST-01	Critical	TGT apps/api/src/modules/admin-customers/admin-customers.service.ts:231-233	First and last name collapse. The reference stores fname/lname as two columns; the target merged them into fullName and returns fname: c.fullName, lname: ''. Opening any edit form puts the whole name in the first-name box and blanks the surname; saving then persists that. singleCustomer.vue tries to compensate with split(' '), which mis-splits multi-part names.	REF database/migrations/2020_10_01_120430_customers_table.php:18-19 (two columns) vs TGT :231-233. Reported by the user from live use.	FIXING — D0
CUST-02	Critical	TGT same file :245, :600-658	percent read from the wrong entity and never written. Target returns c.referredByAgent?.wagePercent; the reference reads the customer's own percent column. update() ignores data.percent entirely, so editing the field does nothing. The create-time default (3) and the admin-path required rule are both missing, as is the app-side filterPercentPay offset.	REF database/migrations/2020_10_19_153228_customer_add.php:32; AdminController.php:338,354; ApiMobileController.php:391-396,76-77. Full trace in DECISIONS.md §percent.	FIXING — D9
CUST-03	High	TGT apps/admin-panel/src/views/apps/customer/ReagentCustomer.vue:97-110	Sales-expert form is missing 5 reference fields: ncode, phone, city_id, gram_level, reagent_id. The reference form had 15; the target has 8. Likely because AdminUser lacks those columns.	REF henza_admin/src/views/apps/customer/ReagentCustomer.vue (15 v-decorator fields) vs TGT form object.	INVESTIGATING — D10
CUST-04	Low	TGT apps/admin-panel/src/views/apps/customer/singleCustomer.vue:91	Still spreads the whole form on save while the other two customer forms send a diff. Harmless today (4 fields, all repopulated) but the same shape that caused the earlier data loss.	read at :80-106	FIXING — D11
CUST-05	Low	TGT apps/admin-panel/src/views/apps/customer/bulkCustomer.vue	Diff-send on edit is a deliberate deviation from the reference, which posts all 15 fields on every save. Recorded so it is not "fixed" back.	DECISIONS.md D11	accepted deviation

Money, stock & data integrity

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Suggested fix
MON-01	Critical	TGT apps/user-app-v2/src/stores/cartStore.ts	v2 has no capQty / maxQty stock ceiling, which user-app does have (apps/user-app/src/stores/cartStore.ts:62,65; components/product/CartItem.vue:82-83). A v2 user can order more units than exist.	Verified by grep across both apps — zero hits in v2.	Port the ceiling to v2 (this is also a Phase 2 parity gap, row to be added to 02-APPS-MATRIX.md).
MON-02	High	REF henza_server wallet package	The wallet balance column mixes grams and toman in one field, and money operations are not wrapped in DB transactions.	_inv-ref-server.md §7.	Separate the units; wrap mutations in transactions.
MON-03	High	TGT apps/api/src/modules/accounting/ledger.service.ts:189	GRAMS_PER_MESGHAL = 4.331802 is a JS float used inside an otherwise-Prisma.Decimal CASH repayment formula, so the divisor is pre-rounded before the Decimal division.	Read at ledger.service.ts:182-190; the source comment already flags the formula for stakeholder review.	Make the constant a Decimal (or a string literal passed to Decimal).
MON-04	High	TGT apps/api/src/modules/orders/orders.service.ts	Debt is recognised at DELIVERED_TO_AGENT, but the idempotency guard checks deliveredAt, which is only set by DELIVERED_TO_CUSTOMER — so the debt trigger is not reliably idempotent. There is also no status-transition validation anywhere.	api inventory §8.	Guard on the same field the trigger fires on; add an explicit transition table.
MON-05	Medium	TGT apps/api	canPlaceOrders and verificationStep are stored and toggled by the admin panel but never enforced on any order path.	api inventory §8.	Enforce at order creation, or remove the toggles.
MON-06	Medium	TGT apps/api	Setting rows are never seeded — wallet.config, wallet.birthday, promotion.auto, mobile_main_slider only materialise on first write, so a fresh install has undefined behaviour until an admin saves each one.	api inventory §7.	Seed the defaults.
MON-07	Medium	REF henza_server/app/Models/ProductVariant.php:183-190 vs SingleCustomerOrders.php:67, Order.php:66	Two divergent order-status enums coexist (0–6 and 1–7) for what is conceptually one flow.	Read both models.	Unify, or document the mapping explicitly.

Validation & contracts

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Suggested fix
VAL-01	High	REF henza_server	Zero FormRequests; all validation is inline, and setOrder, wallet charge, setConst and file upload have no validation at all. The wallet package's own validator is dead code (it calls failed() instead of fails()).	_inv-ref-server.md §12.	n/a in reference; informs how much validation the target must add.
VAL-02	High	TGT apps/api	Only 8 DTO classes exist; most admin request bodies are untyped Record<string, unknown>, so class-validator never runs on them.	api inventory §5.	Add DTOs for the admin write paths.
VAL-03	Medium	TGT both user apps	HTTP client is a bare fetch wrapper: no interceptors, no Authorization header, no refresh, no 401 handling, no error toasts. Non-2xx throws a generic Error; call sites mostly console.log(e). Order-submit failure is silent to the user.	apps/user-app/src/api/client.ts, apps/user-app-v2/src/api/client.ts:3.	Add a shared client with error surfacing; compare against henza_pwa/src/service/* in Phase 2.

Parity-relevant divergence between user-app and user-app-v2

CLAUDE.md §2: the only allowed difference is visual design. These are logic differences, so they are Phase 2 parity gaps as well as issues.

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence
V2-01	Critical	v2 missing stock ceiling	see MON-01	grep
V2-02	Medium	v2 missing getHomeSlider() / GET /home/slider admin banner	v1 api/client.ts:152-170 defines AdminSlide + getHomeSlider; v2 has neither	diff apps/user-app/src/api/client.ts apps/user-app-v2/src/api/client.ts
V2-03	Medium	v2 missing per-variant images	v1 defines ProductImageSummary (id/url/sortOrder/role) and imageId/image on the variant; v2's images is just Array<{url:string}>	same diff
V2-04	Medium	v2 missing orderable-first variant defaulting	v1 composables/useProduct.ts:26 picks the first orderable variant; v2 has no equivalent	grep
V2-05	Low	v2 missing variant-chip preview cap + per-chip stock badges	v1 components/product/SingleProduct.vue:388-392	grep

Dead code & maintenance

ID	Severity	Where	Description
DEAD-01	Low	TGT apps/user-app	8 components with no importers, loadingStore, api.getBalance (zero call sites), unused gsap dependency.
DEAD-02	Low	TGT apps/user-app-v2	11 dead components, loadingStore, getBalance, priceUnit/priceUnitRialLess, 12 of 15 validators, unused gsap + @ant-design/icons-vue deps.
DEAD-03	Low	TGT gold-banking-monorepo/user-app-v2/ (repo root, outside apps/)	Stray leftover folder containing only package.json and an older vite.config.ts (hardcoded port 5179, hardcoded proxy, imports a themeConfig that doesn't exist there). Not matched by pnpm-workspace.yaml, so pnpm ignores it. Left in place — deleting it needs user approval.
DEAD-04	Low	REF henza_server/app/Console/Kernel.php	schedule() is empty — no cron. Price refresh / expiry / birthday logic must be driven by OS cron or the GET / web route.
DEAD-05	Low	REF henza_server	PayPing returnUrl points at site/transaction/verify, which is not registered in any route file — the payment callback is unreachable.

Known stubs in the target (not bugs, but not parity either)

ID	Where	Description
STUB-01	TGT both user apps	Registration persists nothing; favourites are in-memory only (lost on reload); notifications is a static empty state; home slides are 3 hardcoded placeholders in v2.
STUB-02	TGT apps/api	No OTP, no SMS provider, no payment gateway/callbacks, no cron, no websockets. SMS and notifications are DB-persistence only.
STUB-03	TGT both user apps	All list filtering and "pagination" is client-side over one flat GET /catalog/products; no server page/limit params. "Pagination" is a 20-item IntersectionObserver window.
STUB-04	TGT both user apps	Live price is pull-on-mount only (GET /pricing/latest?karatPerMille=750) — no socket, no SSE, no polling interval. quotedAt renders as a Jalali date only, so a stale rate looks current.

Found during the stage-3 OTP audit

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Status
SEC-11	High	TGT apps/api/src/modules/customer-auth/customer-auth.service.ts (deliver)	The OTP message text, code included, was persisted to SmsMessage.body, which the admin SMS grid lists and full-text searches (admin-misc.service.ts:135-136). Any operator holding the sms rid could read live codes — defeating the bcrypt hashing of codeHash.	Read both files; grid allowed includes body.	✅ Fixed in stage 3: the persisted row is a redacted audit line.
MON-08	Medium	TGT apps/api/src/modules/orders/orders.service.ts:40-52	wagePercent, discountPercent and flatRialCharge are taken from the client on order creation, so a caller can set their own making charge. rashWeightGrams is correctly read from the variant. The reference is worse — ApiMobileController.php:538-539,619 takes rash_weight from the client too — so this is a partial improvement already. Reported per the user's instruction to flag client-supplied pricing.	REF :536-545,615-632 vs TGT :40-52	Log only (D4). Fix in Phase 2 alongside the price-formula work.

Found while classifying scope for D13

ID	Severity	Where	Description	Evidence	Status
DOC-01	Medium	DOC docs/parity/_inv-ref-server.md:588 (§3.6)	The Phase 0 inventory undercounted routes/admin.php: it recorded 117 explicit routes where the file has 151 live ones (6 more are commented out). Every downstream total inherited the error, so the reference endpoint count was reported as 369 when it is 412 (admin 249, not 215). No code is affected — only the planning figures.	grep -E "^\s*Route::(get|post|put|patch|delete|any)" routes/admin.php | grep -v "^\s*//" | wc -l → 151; resources 14×7=98; 151+98=249	✅ Corrected in 00-INVENTORY.md §2.1 and DECISIONS.md §D13. _inv-ref-server.md left as the raw subagent record.
DOC-02	Low	REF routes/admin.php:38	GET admin/get-analytics-tak reads SingleCustomerOrders (Adm/AdminController.php:557-579), so it is a retail-storefront endpoint despite its neutral name. A keyword scan for wallet|single|comment misses it. Noted so the D13 scope split stays correct — anything else named neutrally but querying SingleCustomerOrders, Fav, Address, Comment or Transaction is storefront too.	AdminController.php:563 — SingleCustomerOrders::select(...)	✅ Classified as ⏸️ storefront in D13 (the 31st admin storefront route).