The user declined to defer this to Phase 2, correctly: a public POST /orders with customerId in the body let anyone place an order on any customer's account, and an order lands on that customer's gold debt and ledger. POST /orders is now behind CustomerAuth. OrdersService.createOrder takes the customer id as a separate argument that the controller fills from the token; the body's customerId is ignored and a mismatch is logged. The field stays optional in the DTO and in shared-types only so both apps keep validating while they still send it -- they drop it in Phase 2. The admin builder is unaffected: it legitimately places orders for a chosen customer and passes that id explicitly, behind the admin guard. GET /orders/:id is scoped to the owner. A foreign or nonexistent id both return 404, never 403, so ids stay unenumerable. Operators read through the new GET /orders/admin/:id behind rid order.list, declared before the :id route because Nest matches in declaration order. Both apps' CartView now gates on session.isLoggedIn rather than a remembered customerId, which is no longer a credential. OTP audit (requested): no master code, no bypass, no hardcoded code anywhere; one code path issues a token and only after bcrypt.compare. No SMS provider is wired up -- in development the code is logged once, guarded by NODE_ENV !== 'production'. Fixed while auditing (SEC-11): deliver() persisted the real message text, code included, into SmsMessage.body, which the admin SMS grid lists and full-text searches. Any operator with the sms rid could read live codes, defeating the hashing of codeHash. The stored row is now a redacted audit line. Also logged MON-08: wagePercent/discountPercent/flatRialCharge are still taken from the client on order creation. The reference is worse -- it takes rash_weight from the client too -- so this is already a partial improvement; logged rather than changed, per D4. Tests: auth-smoke.sh now 53 passed, 0 failed, including a spoofed body customerId being ignored in favour of the token. Typecheck clean on api, user-app, user-app-v2 and shared-types. [ref: henza_server ApiMobileController.php:533,536-545,615-632] Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
12 KiB
CHANGELOG — parity changes
Every change made to gold-banking-monorepo during the parity project, with the
reason and the reference path that justifies it.
Format:
## <date> — <phase> — <group title>
- **What:** <the change>
- **Why:** <the parity gap it closes>
- **Reference:** <henza_* path:line>
- **Target:** <gold-banking-monorepo path:line>
- **Matrix row:** <id in 01-ADMIN-MATRIX.md / 02-APPS-MATRIX.md>
- **Commit:** <sha>
2026-09-21 — Phase 0 — Setup
- What: Created branch
parity/phase-0anddocs/parity/scaffolding (PROGRESS.md,ISSUES.md,CHANGELOG.md). - Why: Persistent state required by
CLAUDE.md§6. - Reference: n/a
- Target:
docs/parity/ - Matrix row: n/a
No source code changed in Phase 0 (read-only phase).
2026-09-22 — Security hotfix, stage 1 — close the unauthenticated write paths
Branch parity/security-hotfix. Authorised by the user's rulings D7, T1–T3.
1. Ledger routes are admin-only (SEC-09)
- What: removed the controller-level
@Public()fromAccountingControllerand gave each route a rid:wallet.list(balance),wallet.charge(reconcile),document.create(both repayments),document.list.confirm(confirm entry). - Why: four of the five routes WRITE to the ledger and were reachable with no token at all. Faithful to the reference, whose entire admin route file is unauthenticated, but contrary to confirmed decision D1.
- Reference:
henza_server/routes/admin.php:12,272(theauth:apiwrapper is commented out at both ends) - Target:
apps/api/src/modules/accounting/accounting.controller.ts - Breakage check:
api.getBalance()is the only app-side consumer and it has zero call sites in either user app (dead code, already logged as DEAD-01/02).
2. Order status change is admin-only (SEC-10)
- What: moved
@Public()from the class to the two customer-facing handlers, leavingPATCH orders/:id/statusbehindorder.list.sts.submit. - Why: it let an anonymous caller move any order's status and attribute
the change to any admin through the DTO's
actorAdminUserId. - Reference: an admin operation; the admin panel posts to
admin/orders/status(apps/admin-panel/src/api/endpoints.ts:42,48), so this route had no caller. - Target:
apps/api/src/modules/orders/orders.controller.ts - Still public:
POST /ordersandGET /orders/:id, because the target has no customer session yet — closed in stage 2.
3. GET /customers no longer leaks the customer book (SEC-08)
- What: added
LOGIN_LOOKUP_SELECT(id,mobile,isActive,isArchived) and pointedlist()at it. RemovedfullName,nationalCode,goldDebtGrams,fiatDebtRial,goldCreditLimitGrams,verificationStep,cityId,referredByAgentId,nationalIdImageUrl,businessLicenseUrl,shopImageUrl,createdAt,updatedAtfrom that response. - Why: the route is unauthenticated because both apps match the phone number in the browser, so it shipped every customer's national ID number, debts, credit limit and identity-document URLs to any visitor.
- Reference: login was
POST userAuth→ SMS →POST userVerfiy, returning exactly one customer after the code matched (henza_server/app/Http/Controllers/Api/ApiMobileController.php:39-78). - Target:
apps/api/src/modules/customers/customers.service.ts, plusCustomerSummarynarrowed in both apps'src/api/client.ts(parity rule: the same logic change in both). - Route survives until stage 2 replaces the client-side phone match with OTP.
4. Test script
- What: added
apps/api/scripts/auth-smoke.sh— asserts 401 without a token, 403 with a low-privilege token, and pass-through for a super admin, on every closed route; plus that the public routes still answer 200 and thatGET /customersexposes only the four login fields. - Result: 23 passed, 0 failed against a live server and the dev seed.
Not changed
/uploads — per ruling T2, uploaded files including identity documents stay
public. The filename check requested alongside it passed with no changes needed
(md5 of time + name + UUID; no directory listing).
2026-09-22 — Security hotfix, stage 2 — real customer sessions
Branch parity/security-hotfix. Authorised by D6, D7, T1 and T3.
Stage 1 narrowed GET /customers but, as the user pointed out, did not close
the leak: the response still carried every customer id, and
/customers/:id, /:id/orders and /:id/ledger-entries were still public — so
two requests still reconstructed the whole book. Stage 2 removes the id-bearing
surface entirely.
1. Customer JWT, separate from the admin one (T1)
- New:
src/modules/customer-auth/—CustomerJwtStrategy(passport strategy'customer-jwt'),CustomerJwtGuard,@CustomerAuth(),@CurrentCustomer(). - Signed with
JWT_CUSTOMER_SECRET, separate fromJWT_SECRET, and every token carriestyp: 'customer'which the strategy verifies. Either check alone would be enough; both are present deliberately. - Customer state is re-read from the DB on every request, so deactivating or archiving a customer takes effect at once rather than at token expiry.
- Reference: the same split existed there —
auth:apifor admins,auth('api-customer')for the app.
2. Real OTP (D6)
- New table
CustomerOtp(migration20260922000000_customer_otp, additive: one new table, nothing existing touched). POST /api/customer/auth/request-otp←ApiMobileController::userAuth(:39-49)POST /api/customer/auth/verify-otp←ApiMobileController::userVerfiy(:51-64)- Parity behaviour: the 4-digit
rand(1000,9999)range, the active-customer filter,Utility::faTOen()digit normalisation on both the number and the code, and rejection on mismatch. - Deliberate improvements over the reference (user-approved, recorded in
DECISIONS.md so the matrix does not flag them later):
- the code is stored as a bcrypt hash, never plain text;
- it expires after 2 minutes (the reference's never did);
- 5 attempts per challenge, then lockout (the reference had no limit);
- single use — a consumed code cannot be replayed;
- send throttle: 60s cooldown per number, 5 per number and 20 per IP per 10 minutes, counted off the table so it survives restarts;
- no enumeration — an unregistered number returns the same
{sent:true}. The reference'sfirstOrFail()leaked a 404 for unknown numbers.
- No SMS gateway exists in this project (STUB-02), so the code is logged in
non-production only and the message is persisted as an
SmsMessagerow. The reference's message text is kept verbatim for when a gateway lands.
3. The id-bearing customer routes are gone
- Deleted
customers.controller.ts— with itGET /customers,/customers/:id,/:id/orders,/:id/ledger-entries. - Replaced by
/api/customer/me,/me/orders,/me/ledger-entries, which take the id from the token. There is no longer any route that accepts a customer id, so the IDOR is closed structurally rather than by a check. CustomersServicestays and is reached only through those routes.- The admin panel was unaffected — it uses
admin/customers-omde/*.
4. Both apps migrated together (parity rule)
stores/session.ts:tokenis now the credential andisLoggedInis token-based.customerIdis kept for display only and is no longer an identity claim.api/client.ts: sendsAuthorization: Bearer, throwsUnauthorizedErroron 401 and calls the handler registered inmain.ts, which clears the session and routes to login so stale personal data cannot stay on screen.LoginView.vue: real two-step OTP. Each app keeps its own markup and styling; only the logic changed, and it is identical in both.- The four account screens now call
getMe()/getMyOrders()/getMyLedgerEntries(); router guards testisLoggedIn.
Tests
apps/api/scripts/auth-smoke.shextended with the stage-2 assertions: 46 passed, 0 failed against a live server — old routes 404, customer routes 401 without a token, wrong/reused code 401, correct code 200, throttle 429, no enumeration, customer token rejected on admin routes and admin token rejected on customer routes, no id-bearing surface, and/customer/mereturning the token's own customer.- jest installed (dev-only, user-approved) with
jest.config.cjs, sopnpm testworks for the first time: 7 passed coveringfaToEn.faToEnmoved to its owndigits.tsso it can be tested without booting Nest. - Typecheck clean on api, user-app and user-app-v2; both apps build.
2026-09-22 — Security hotfix, stage 3 — SEC-02 (orders) + OTP audit
Branch parity/security-hotfix. The user declined to defer SEC-02 to Phase 2:
a public POST /orders taking customerId from the body let anyone place an
order on any customer's account, and an order lands on that customer's gold
debt and ledger. That is a money hole, so it is closed here.
1. POST /orders is customer-authenticated
- What: the route is behind
@CustomerAuth().OrdersService.createOrdernow takescustomerIdas a separate argument, supplied by the controller from the token. The body'scustomerIdis ignored entirely; a mismatch is logged (OrdersServicewarn) and the token always wins. CreateOrderDto.customerIdand the sharedCreateOrderDtoare optional, so both apps keep validating while they still send it. Removed in Phase 2.- Reference:
ApiMobileController::setOrderreadauth()->id()(henza_server:533) behind theapi-customerguard — this restores that. - Admin path unaffected:
AdminOrdersServiceplaces orders for a selected customer and passes that id explicitly; its route is admin-guarded.
2. GET /orders/:id is scoped to the owner
getOwnedById(orderId, customerId)matches on both, and a miss is 404, not 403 — a 403 would confirm the id exists, the same enumeration leak the old/customers/:idroutes had. A nonexistent id and someone else's id are indistinguishable.- Operators use the new
GET /orders/admin/:idbehind ridorder.list. Declared before:idbecause Nest matches in declaration order.
3. Both apps
CartView.vuein both apps now gates onsession.isLoggedIn(the token) rather than on a rememberedcustomerId, which is no longer a credential.
4. OTP audit (user request 3)
- No master code, no bypass, no hardcoded code anywhere in the API or either
app — verified by grep for
master.?code|bypass|backdoor|1111|0000|1234|skipOtp|DEV_OTP|TEST_OTP. Exactly one code path issues a token, and only afterbcrypt.compare. - SMS provider: none. No gateway is wired up (STUB-02). In development the
code is logged once via
Logger, guarded byNODE_ENV !== 'production'. - Fixed while auditing:
deliver()persisted the real message text — with the code in it — intoSmsMessage.body, which the admin SMS grid both lists and full-text searches (admin-misc.service.ts:135-136). Any operator with thesmsrid could read live OTP codes, defeating the point of hashingcodeHash. The persisted row is now a redacted audit line; the real text is built for the future gateway and not stored. The 9 test rows created during this session were deleted.
Tests
apps/api/scripts/auth-smoke.sh extended again — 53 passed, 0 failed:
order routes 401 without a token, a spoofed body customerId ignored in favour
of the token, own order readable, unknown/foreign order id 404, and the admin
order route rejecting a customer token while admitting an admin one.
Typecheck clean on api, user-app, user-app-v2 and shared-types.